6
Tennis
5
Predictions game
Forum
9 Commentaires
Partager
Suivez-nous

French Open controversy. Zverev wronged by a refereeing decision in the final?

Le 09/06/2024 à 19h57 par Guillem Casulleras Punsa
French Open controversy. Zverev wronged by a refereeing decision in the final?

It's likely to cause quite a stir. The 5th set of the Roland-Garros 2024 final (6-2) was allegedly marked by a refereeing error at a crucial moment.

With Carlos Alcaraz leading 2-1 and a break ahead, he saved a break point at 15-40 after serving a second service ball that was apparently a fault, but which the chair umpire deemed to have hit the line.

This error was confirmed by video modelling (Hawk-Eye system) available to the media, but not accessible to the chair umpire. It should be noted, however, that a small margin of error exists with the Hawk-Eye, so it may not be possible to conclude with 100% certainty. To be confirmed.

If the error is confirmed, Alexander Zverev should have come back to 2 games all in this final set, which would then have been completely different.

GER Zverev, Alexander  [4]
3
6
7
1
2
ESP Alcaraz, Carlos  [3]
tick
6
2
5
6
6
Comments
sync
send Send
warning Règles à respecter
Avatar
Fred Phoesh
8
Tradition is nice but really come on People

, we need to have hawkeye for all of these games!
audreyharpist
8
I agree . Can't understand the refusal to use hawkeye when there is a disputed call.
Angela R.
2
It’s nice to have technology to assist with precision. When available it should be used to ease any stress and eliminate uncertainty, to prevent players from losing their rhythm
FragMuffins
1
FragMuffins @FragMuffins  just talking tennis
Don't care, Zverev should never win a slam
StAdam
1
They should also get rid of the electronic scoreboard.



They should have two people writing on the Chalkboards instead.
Angela R.
0
Great match 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Christine N
star star
0
In a zverev service game in the same set (5th) one of his own serves was called in when it was out...and not nearly as close as the serve of Alcaraz'. The umpire came down, called it in, and Carlos just scuffed it out and moved on. The difference...Alcaraz didn't have a mental breakdown like zverev did. Zverev has a weak mind when things don't go his way. His temperament gets the better of him.



Besides. In the game, after the missed call, zverev had three more opportunities to break.



I think it's clear that Alcaraz was the stronger of the two at the end of the match.
Christine N
star star
0
That being said. I too think it would be good for the game if Roland Garros to get on board with hawk eye.
SH321
0
Players have to sign contracts to play in the tournaments and most often those contain clauses regarding PR relations which preclude players making negative comments about the tournament, tournament officials and employees.
À lire aussi
Van de Zandschulp praises Alcaraz: He's probably got the best forehand on the circuit.
Van de Zandschulp praises Alcaraz: "He's probably got the best forehand on the circuit".
Jules Hypolite 05/02/2025 à 20h57
Beaten by Carlos Alcaraz yesterday in Rotterdam, Botic Van de Zandschulp held his own against the Spaniard before cracking in a two-and-a-half-hour battle. Speaking at the press conference, the Dutch...
Alcaraz on bullets: We need to change something.
Alcaraz on bullets: "We need to change something".
Clément Gehl 05/02/2025 à 10h33
Carlos Alcaraz beat Botic van de Zandschulp not without difficulty on Tuesday evening in Rotterdam. In the post-match press conference, he talked about his match and the balls. He said: "I knew ther...
The list of players attending Indian Wells has been unveiled, with no absentees for the moment.
The list of players attending Indian Wells has been unveiled, with no absentees for the moment.
Clément Gehl 05/02/2025 à 10h23
The list of players taking part in the Indian Wells Masters 1000 has been unveiled. For the moment, the first 76 entrants are the world's top 76, which means that there are no withdrawals for the time...
Alcaraz struggles to beat Van de Zandschulp on his Rotterdam debut
Alcaraz struggles to beat Van de Zandschulp on his Rotterdam debut
Jules Hypolite 04/02/2025 à 22h29
Carlos Alcaraz made his Rotterdam debut with a hard-fought victory over Botic Van de Zandschulp (7-6, 3-6, 6-1). Weakened by a cold over the last few days, the world No.3 was very inconsistent, again...